Cats are so cute, and such independent beings that you might not be able to have just one of them! Whether you have tons of space, or just enough, you’ll probably want to maximize your area for multiple pets.
How do you do that, though? What is the best cat litter for multiple cats?
With so many cat litters out there, from clumping litters to clay cat litters, cat owners may have a hard time deciding between kitty litter for their multi-cat households.
This is normal, but we’ve found some of the best litters for multiple cats so that you don’t have to.
As you work to find the perfect litter box system for you and your cats, whether you have two cats or more, you’ll want to consider things like size, shape, what has the best odor protection, and more. These considerations will help you handle multiple cats in the best way.
Product
Details
Top Pick
Dr. Elsey’s Premium Clumping Cat Litter
- Material: Clay Litter
- Item Weight: 40 pounds
Dust-free Option
World’s Best Cat Litter, Multiple Cat
- Material: Corn
- Item Weight: 32 Pounds
Great for Sensitive Cats
Arm & Hammer SLIDE Multi-Cat Clumping Litter
- Material: bentonite clay
- Item Weight: 19 pounds
Super Absorbent
Naturally Fresh Cat Litter
- Material: Walnut
- Item Weight: 26 pounds
Less Tracking
ÖKOCAT Less Mess Natural Wood Clumping Cat Litter
- Material: Wood
- Item Weight: 18.6 Pounds
Extra Strength
Ever Clean Extra Strength Cat Litter
- Material: Clay
- Item Weight: 1 Pounds
Super Lightweight
Cat’s Pride Max Power Clumping Clay
- Material: Clay
- Item Weight: 15 Pounds
Scented Option
Purina Tidy Cats Lightweight Clumping Cat Litter
- Material: Clay
- Item Weight: 1.08 Pounds
Best Cat Litter for Multiple Cats
When looking to find the best cat litter that best suits your cats, you’ll want to make sure that odor protection, ease of cleaning, price, and tracking are kept in mind.
One cat might be slightly easier to keep up with, from cleaning a little extra litter dust to ignoring any slight odors, but once you have two or more cats, you’ll need to focus on products that are reliable but also won’t break the bank.
1. Dr. Elsey’s Premium Clumping Cat Litter
Dr. Elsey’s puts a premium focus on using natural ingredients to create superior odor control and keep dust tracking at an all-time low. It’s strong enough to support the comings and goings of multiple cats and is easy enough for you to clean up. What more could you ask for, really?
You’d expect the premium quality of this litter, its 100% bentonite clay, to make it more expensive, but luckily this isn’t the case.
This multi-cat litter is hypoallergenic and unscented, which makes it perfect for sensitive cats. Cats who avoid certain litter may just not feel good around them, and I can attest that any cat I’ve seen with this clumping clay litter seems to be happy.
The litter is medium-sized in its grain, so it is easily clumped, and you can scoop any dirty litter out, but your cat won’t be likely to drag much of it around the house.
If you are a multi-cat owner, you know the pain that tracking can be, and this litter will help you to prevent litter tracking!
Pros
- Affordable
- Low tracking because of large granules
- Good odor control
- Unscented
- Clumps well
- Hypoallergenic litter formulation
Cons
- Not 100% dust free
- A bit heavier because of the way litter forms hard clumps
Dr. Elsey’s Premium Clumping Cat Litter
The price of “Dr. Elsey’s Premium Clumping Cat Litter ” varies, so check the latest price at
2. World’s Best Cat Litter, Multiple Cat
Another favorite of my cat-owning friends tends to be World’s Best Cat Litter, which uses corn granules. Talk about a sustainable solution that is both eco-friendly and truly works!
Their patented process compresses the corn into smaller granules that can form tight scoopable solid clumps that make your cleaning easier but also happen to be comfortable for your cats to utilize.
One thing about having multiple cats is that you feel like you’re buying food, litter, and other products more than you might have expected, at least at first. The compression of these granules of litter makes it so that you have to use less to see results.
It’s nice to need a reasonable amount of litter, even when you have multiple cats using it! Not to worry, though, the odor control is hard to believe because it works so well.
Another perk of this litter is that it happens to be safe for septic and sewer systems, which is miles ahead of many other cat litter products. Cleaning up is even easier with this litter, and you don’t have to worry about any unforeseen clogging.
Pros
- Clumps quickly
- Great odor control
- 99% dust free (and it’s true!)
- Flushable
- Unscented
- Environmentally friendly
Cons
- Slightly more expensive
World’s Best Cat Litter, Multiple Cat
The price of “World’s Best Cat Litter, Multiple Cat” varies, so check the latest price at
3. Arm & Hammer SLIDE Multi-Cat Clumping Litter
This Arm & Hammer SLIDE clumping litter is simple but quite effective. Its granules utilize plant-based elements that are activated by moisture and create scoopable clumps that are hard and easy to remove.
Speaking of the plant-derived granule particles, this litter is quite a bit more eco-friendlier than some of its competitors. Why not feel good about your contributions to sustainability while giving your kitty the best cat litter?
This one is great for sensitive cats because this multiple cat litter itself is soft to walk on, while the science behind it helps eliminate odors without extra added fragrances.
The odor-eliminating technology is strong enough for a multi-cat household, and the difference is noticeable between this and a kitty litter that is intended to work for just one cat at a time.
After all, two cats produce double the standard amount of solid waste throughout a week, so you’ll want to make sure to account for this. It’s nice to rest assured that your multi-cat litter will be able to handle and trap odors that might come up.
Pros
- Unscented
- All natural
- Environmentally friendly
- Soft texture for sensitive paws
- Non-stick
- 100% dust-free
- Clumps well
Cons
- Litter can get mushy because of how soft it is
- Needs fully emptied out a bit more than other litter types
Arm & Hammer SLIDE Multi-Cat Clumping Litter
The price of “Arm & Hammer SLIDE Multi-Cat Clumping Litter” varies, so check the latest price at
4. Naturally Fresh Cat Litter
Where sustainability meets long-lasting litter, you’ll find Naturally Fresh litter. I always hear great things about this one, which is branded as being 3x as absorbent as similar products.
It seems that the claims are true because it tends to last about 2 to 3 times as other multi-cat litter, according to a friend who swears by this brand.
This absorbent litter is made from organic walnut shells, making it extremely eco-friendly, as well as helping you to avoid getting dust tracked through your home.
Since the natural litter won’t get stuck to your cats’ paws in the same way that clay-based types might, you can sleep easy in the knowledge that your house is clean and everyone in it will have a better time breathing.
You might wonder how this natural option compares to other, more traditional clay cat litter, but it produces easy-to-clean clumps of waste, too.
This might also win the ‘most eco-friendly’ award out of the litter in this list, because of its non-toxic, plant-based formula that comes in packaging that is 30% recycled. The walnuts that are turned into litter are non-GMO and help to create an organic way to neutralize odors.
Pros
- Eco-friendly
- Unscented
- All-natural
- Dust-free
- Clumps quickly
Cons
- Litter might get mushy because it is softer
Naturally Fresh Cat Litter
The price of “Naturally Fresh Cat Litter” varies, so check the latest price at
5. ÖKOCAT Less Mess Natural Wood Clumping Cat Litter
A solid, trustworthy pellet cat litter is a good essential, and OKOCAT puts just the right focus on creating absorbent cat litter pellets that are less likely to be tracked through the house.
The plant-based litter aims to be extra safe for your furry friends because there are no artificial fragrances, synthetic chemicals, toxic dyes, or GMOs.
Not only is this healthier for your cat, and better for the environment in general, but it means that sensitive cats have less of a chance to react poorly to any fragrances, dyes, or chemicals that other litters may utilize.
I will say that this one has a bit more dust than advertised, but because it is wood based, this is not surprising. Overall, it helps to limit tracking and dust and clumps very well. The ease of manually cleaning up litter with this one makes it more worth using, even if there is more dust than expected.
You can expect to be able to go so far as to compost this clumping cat litter because it is biodegradable. This could make it easier if you want to focus on the environment while maintaining an easy routine with multi-cat litter than can be cleaned up quickly.
Pros
- Eco-friendly
- Less dust than most
- Great odor control
- Recyclable packaging
Cons
- Litter is a bit dustier than advertised when dry
- When wet, the litter can get a but mushy
ÖKOCAT Less Mess Natural Wood Clumping Cat Litter
The price of “ÖKOCAT Less Mess Natural Wood Clumping Cat Litter ” varies, so check the latest price at
6. Ever Clean Extra Strength Cat Litter
With extra cats come extra smells, which is why the Ever Clean Extra Strength litter can also be a great option for multi-cat households.
Everyone I’ve heard talk about this has said that the litter is a bit heavier than sand and works super well when it comes to keeping things clean. When it’s dry, it never sticks to paws and tracking doesn’t seem to be an issue here.
It’s also not dusty litter in general, so you don’t have to worry about a dust cloud forming as you pour the litter into the litterbox.
With no scent of its own, it’s a wonder that this product is so great at stopping odor altogether. You can also use this with litter robots and other products that work to help you automatically clean up after your cats.
Since the product is extra strength, you can rest assured that your home will not begin smelling bad when you introduce another cat into the mix. It’s made of natural minerals and clays to provide the best clean-up and will clump easily as it works to eliminate odors.
Pros
- Less dust than most
- Great odor control
- Made of natural materials
- Unscented
Cons
- Not 100% dust-free
Ever Clean Extra Strength Cat Litter
The price of “Ever Clean Extra Strength Cat Litter” varies, so check the latest price at
7. Cat’s Pride Max Power Clumping Clay
If you’re someone that is less able to work with huge bags of litter, or heavier products, this could be the multi-cat litter for you. Cat’s Pride does a great job at offering a product that doesn’t track much and controls odors very well, all while being manageable and reliable.
Aside from this being lightweight to pour and replace, you’ll find that this litter clumps so well and makes cleaning feel a little bit less like the nuisance that we know it is.
The absorbent nature of the clay helps, but one highlight that really stands out is that you can flush the clumps down the toilet. While this isn’t the only product that does this, it isn’t even the only one on this list, it certainly makes your clean-up process even easier.
A really cool perk of using this best multi-cat litter is that Cat’s Pride donates a pound of litter to an animal shelter for every jug of their product that is purchased. Not a bad incentive, on top of all the real-world benefits of using this litter.
Pros
- 99% dust-free
- Good odor control
- Clumps well
- Light and easy to pour
- Unscented
Cons
- Litter tracks a bit more than others
- A bit more expensive
Cat’s Pride Max Power Clumping Clay
The price of “Cat’s Pride Max Power Clumping Clay” varies, so check the latest price at
8. Purina Tidy Cats Lightweight Clumping Cat Litter
There are so many clumping litters created specifically to focus on offering easy-to-scoop clumps, because why should you have to do all the work when it comes to cleaning up after your cat?
You might have signed on to care for your furry felines but you deserve a fast-acting natural litter that can help you do the trick. Purina Tidy Cats litter is a popular cat litter brand already, but the lightweight cat litter combines all the things you look for when it comes to trustworthy, easy-to-use cat litter.
While many of the multi-cat litter we talked about today are unscented, this one is scented in a way that is not overpowering and can still be used by those with allergies or sensitive cats. The cat litter releases a deodorant slowly, to prevent ammonia odor from forming for up to two weeks.
On top of the odor control, you can expect less tracking to happen with this low-dust formula, which comes in a weather-proof bag with handles, to make everything easier on you while handling more than one cat.
Pros
- Low-dust litter
- Lightweight cat litter
- Scented with a slow-release deodorant
- Easy to transport/handle as needed
Cons
- Potentially too scented for certain cats
- A bit more expensive
Purina Tidy Cats Lightweight Clumping Cat Litter
The price of “Purina Tidy Cats Lightweight Clumping Cat Litter” varies, so check the latest price at
Things to Consider Before Buying Cat Litters for Multiple Cats
It helps to do your research before buying any type of cat litter products, especially when you have multi-cat households. Clumping ability, silica dust control, ease to clean up, safety, and sustainability are all good starting points.
Dust Control
More than anything else, dust is a nuisance when it gets tracked around your home. This could be something to keep in mind as you search for the best cat litters. Anything that can get you to a point where there is almost no dust is a good contender.
There are many cat litters created specifically with dust control in mind, and there are still a variety of options that allow you to focus on other aspects of your cats’ care, like safety and comfort for them.
Tracking
Speaking of dust, anything that you can do to keep your cats from tracking it, along with pieces of cat litter, around your home, is going to be a welcome change for you.
This is a great point to think about as you determine whether you want clumping cat litter, clay litter, silica litter, or a more natural option like pine pellets.
Ultimately, the mess of tracking goes back to your furry feline bringing dust and small pieces of its litter along with it. When you can avoid this, you will probably want to.
Odor Control
When it comes to odor control, you want cat litter that is going to really do the trick. It’s not possible to completely eradicate odors from your cat, but it is worth taking the time to find a cat litter and look at litter boxes, that will help you eliminate litter box odors the best you can.
Some brands specialize in unscented cat litter that might be best for sensitive cats, while others have stronger fragrances to cover up scents. Things like baking soda are popular additions to cat litter and can often help to soak up unwanted smells.
Safety
Some of the things to consider before buying cat products have more to do with preference and personal wishes. The safety of your cats, though, should be a non-negotiable part of your search.
You’ll want to consider if your cat might be better off with a more natural cat litter, even if it tracks a bit more and leaves you with some dust around your home.
Maybe the option that controls odor slightly less effectively is more highly recommended for the kind of cats you have.
You’ll see that safety considerations may lead you to rule out certain cat litters that you thought were the top contenders, at one stage. It’s always worth it to know that you’re doing the best thing for your pets!
Waste Disposal
How you get rid of your cat litter is not only a question of convenience but also of sustainability. Eco-friendly options are out there, from buying things like walnut shells to simply avoiding the more silica-based products when possible.
Often, more organic cat litter that breaks down over time is easier to remove and dispose of for you, too.
Clumping cat litter is much easier to clean if you have a traditional cat litter box and not a self-cleaning or automatic model. This kind of cat litter also tends to be made of clay, which is not biodegradable, but clay litters are better than other, synthetic products. This part depends on you and your preferences, of course.
Final Thoughts
There are hundreds, if not more, types of cat litter to choose from, and having multiple cats just means that your decision impacts even more lives. The type of cat litter you choose for your furry felines is important. After all, there are lots of resources out there.
If you’re looking for the Best Cat Litter for Odor Control or even just the Best Cat Litter in general, we’ve got you covered!
The right cat litter, combined with the right cat owner, will prove to make all the difference when raising a happy, healthy tabby or two.
