Bullmastiff vs. Rottweiler: Which Guards Homes Better?

Some dogs are born to nap on your lap. And some other dogs are built like tanks and wired to guard your home, your family, and everything in between. So, when it comes to Bullmastiff Vs Rottweiler: which guards homes better? That is the big question we are answering today.

If you live on a farm, in the suburbs, or just want a dog with protective instincts in the city, choosing between these two powerful dog breeds is tough! Both the Bullmastiff and Rottweiler are serious working dogs with deep roots in protection.

But they differ in how they protect, how much training they need, how active they are, and how well they can adapt to different lifestyles. And if they will thrive in your kind of lifestyle?

Let’s break Bullmastiff vs Rottweiler down for all dog lovers.

Bullmastiff vs. Rottweiler: Which Guards Homes Better?

Bullmastiff Vs Rottweiler: Overview at a Glance

Size: Bullmastiff vs. Rottweiler

Okay, first up! Size matters when it comes to guard dogs.

• Bullmastiffs tend to be blocky and big dogs. According to the American Kennel Club, males weigh in around 110-130 pounds, females a little less. They are broad, muscular dogs and have that imposing presence even when lying down. And they do a lot of lying down.

• Rottweilers are also hefty, but slightly more compact. Males weigh between 95-135 pounds with a stronger athletic build. Their body language shows they do police work, even if they are just chilling on the porch. They have that police dog kinda sleek and athletic look.

Verdict: Bullmastiffs tend to be bulkier, but both breeds are large enough to make any intruder think twice.

Appearance and Physical Features

Let’s be honest. Both of these dog breeds look like they mean business.

• The Bullmastiff has a short muzzle, deep chest, and a wrinkly face that somehow manages to look both serious and adorable. Their face may say “nap time,” but their body and size say “don’t mess with my people”. Their dense coat comes in fawn, red, or brindle colors.

• The Rottweiler has that classic black and tan look. They have a square jaw and muscular frame. Their alert expression and confident gait show why they are still being used as police dogs for protection. They have a short and dense coat and almond-shaped eyes.

Bullmastiffs look like gentle giants. Rottweilers give off that intense and always-on-duty vibe.

Temperament and Personality

Here’s where things get interesting… and kind of personal!

• Bullmastiffs tend to be quiet, calm, and super affectionate with their family members. They are great family pets. PDSA mentions they are completely devoted to their family. They are known to be “real softies”.

• They are not the kind of dogs that pick fights, but they will protect you if they sense a threat. If you provide them proper socialization, they can be sweet around children and family pets. But they are not overly playful.

• Rottweilers, on the other hand, are known for their loyalty, confidence, and sometimes stubborn attitude. Yes, they can be aloof and stubborn dogs when told to perform a task they do not want to do, as stated by Britannica. They are more intelligent and task-driven. It makes them slightly more serious about being guard dogs, even more so if they are properly trained.

Both are protective, but the Rottie tends to be more wary of strangers and quicker to react! Bullmastiffs are more of the “watch first, act if needed” type.

Trainability and Intelligence

Let’s talk brains.

• Rottweilers are often seen and perceived as one of the most intelligent dog breeds. They are fast learners and respond really good to consistent training. But you gotta keep them in check. If you let them lead, they will. Literally and figuratively.

• Bullmastiffs are smart, too. But they are a bit more laid back in how they use their smarts. They need firm and loving leadership. And early socialization, too. Or they will decide to do their own thing… slowly!

Both these breeds need experienced owners or at least someone willing to put in the work. They are not your “first-dog-ever” kind of pups. And if you slack on training, you might end up with a powerful dog who is hard to control. Get these animals socialized, or else you risk aggressive tendencies.

Energy Level and Activity Needs

If your idea of fun is a good chase around the house or throwing a tennis ball for hours, maybe skip both of these. But if you want a more chill dog, read on!

• Bullmastiffs tend to be low-energy dogs. Okay, not that low energy that you might consider them lazy. They need regular exercise, but nothing intense. Don’t make them run too much.

• PetMD says they don’t make good running companions. A short walk, some sniffing time, and they are good. Give them a cozy rug and they will be snoring in no time.

• Rottweilers have more mental stimulation needs. They enjoy challenges, learning new tasks, and having a job. That’s why you see them in military or police work. If they don’t get enough to do, they can get bored, and a bored Rottie is a destructive Rottie.

In short, Bullmastiff = slow walks and couch cuddles. Rottweiler = hikes, obedience training, maybe even more agility games.

Lifespan and Longevity

Dogs don’t live long (cue the tears), but it helps to know what you are signing up for.

• Bullmastiffs usually live around 7-9 years. Their large size, unfortunately, does not support longer lifespans.

• Rottweilers tend to live between 9 to 10 years. With a solid routine, good grooming, and regular vet checkups, you might stretch it a bit longer.

Both breeds can suffer from health issues like hip dysplasia and bloat. So, a healthy diet, exercise, and regular checkups are important and non-negotiable.

Conclusion

So… Bullmastiff Vs Rottweiler. Which guards the home better? The ultimate question! Keep in mind that this is not about which is better in general, but which is better for you. Both are protective, powerful, with notable strength, and incredibly loyal. Both need proper training, early socialization, and a strong-willed owner.

And both dogs will protect their families like it were their life mission. Neither is made for apartments, as they need a big space.

• If your vibe is chill, your home is calm, and you want a soft-hearted protector, the Bullmastiff is the dog to nap beside.

• If you are a more active and patient owner who can offer clean space and mental stimulation, exercise, and daily structure, the Rottweiler is your ride-or-die.

Both, Bullmastiff and the Rottweiler are great working dogs with amazing protective instincts. But keep in mind… the best guard dogs are those who are properly trained, well cared for, and raised in love. That’s how you build a home of strength; they will be well-suited to protect.