10 Worst Dogs For First-Time Owners That Could Test Your Patience

Worst Dogs For First-Time Owners

Embarking on the journey of dog ownership is nothing short of magical. It’s a relationship built on mutual care and devotion, where the rewards far outweigh the demands.

However, for those stepping into the world of dog parenting for the first time, the path can be smoother with a more accommodating breed. Choosing the right companion not only enriches your experience but also ensures a seamless transition into pet parenthood.

Remember, owning a dog is a significant commitment, entailing much more than just companionship. It’s about being ready for the responsibility that comes with caring for another living being. For first-time owners, selecting an easy-to-manage breed can make a world of difference, allowing you to fully embrace the joys of dog ownership while learning the essentials of care and training.

To guide you on this exciting journey, we’ll unveil ten breeds that, while wonderful in their own right, might present challenges for those new to the pet parenting scene. Ready to find your perfect furry friend? Let’s dive in!

Worst Dogs For First-Time Owners

Explore why certain dog breeds might be challenging for first-time owners and how to choose the right companion for a harmonious start.

1. Dalmatian

worst dog breeds for first-time owners

Raising a Dalmatian isn’t for everyone. Despite their charming spots, they can show aggression and stubbornness, requiring continuous training to behave. These independent dogs can be quite manipulative, often trying to assert dominance, making consistent discipline crucial.

Dalmatians are also known for their year-round shedding, their white hairs sticking stubbornly to everything, which can be a deal-breaker for some.

As athletic and energetic dogs, they need ample exercise beyond regular walks to prevent boredom-related behaviors like excessive barking and chewing. Without enough activity, a Dalmatian might turn your home and yard into a mess.

2. American Pitbull Terrier

worst dogs to own

American Pit Bull Terriers, while friendly and deeply loyal to their families, present unique challenges for first-time owners. Their friendly demeanor is paired with a stubbornness that demands patience and consistent leadership from their owner.

Training is crucial to establish authority and ensure they understand who’s in charge, requiring a firm but fair approach.

Additionally, owning a Pit Bull carries a heightened sense of responsibility, as these dogs are often under scrutiny. Their behavior, both in public and at home, must exemplify the best of their breed, necessitating daily commitment to their training and socialization.

3. Belgian Malinois

worst dog breeds to own

The Belgian Malinois is a breed that’s both fiercely loyal and impressively trainable, quickly mastering new commands and cues. However, their energy levels are exceptionally high, requiring owners to engage in substantial physical activity to maintain their well-being.

Known for their intense work ethic, protective nature, and powerful presence, Malinois are a substantial commitment, often overwhelming for first-time dog owners. Despite this, they are deeply family-oriented, thriving on interaction and bonding with their human pack both indoors and out.

To ensure a well-adjusted Malinois, a balanced mix of mental stimulation, physical exercise, and socialization is essential. Without this, they may become difficult to manage, displaying behaviors that challenge even experienced dog owners.

4. Akita

worst dog breeds

Akitas are majestic pets suited for those with experience in handling large, strong breeds. Their complex personality and subtle cues make them a breed that’s not only hard to interpret but also to raise.

Known for their potential aggression towards other dogs of the same sex, it’s advisable never to leave two Akitas together unsupervised. Additionally, their protective nature towards strangers necessitates early and extensive socialization. Akitas are also heavy shedders, so expect to find their fur on almost every surface.

Training an Akita presents its own set of challenges due to their assertive and strong-willed nature, coupled with a tendency to get bored easily.

5. Border Collie

hardest dogs to own

Border Collies stand out in the canine world for their remarkable intelligence and quick learning capabilities. Their desire to please makes them relatively easy to train. However, their boundless energy and sharp minds may not make them the ideal match for first-time dog owners.

Originating as herding dogs, Border Collies possess strong instincts to work and require ample mental stimulation and physical exercise to prevent the development of behavioral issues.

As one of the most demanding breeds in terms of maintenance, Border Collies need more than just physical exercise; they thrive on challenges that keep their agile minds occupied, making them a commitment that extends well beyond basic pet care.

6. Saint Bernard

worst dog breeds for first time owners

Saint Bernards, known for their large size, can be quite stubborn, making it challenging for owners to guide them. Early socialization is crucial for Saint Bernards; without it, their innate caution may escalate into shyness, suspicion, or even aggression.

Be prepared for their shedding; Saint Bernards lose hair copiously, leaving fur on virtually every surface from clothing to kitchen counters, which can be a significant consideration for cleanliness and allergies within the household.

Additionally, their drooling is notable; after meals or drinks, expect to clean up saliva from both yourself and your furniture.

7. German Shepherd

best starter dogs

The German Shepherd Dog (GSD) stands out for its loyalty, intelligence, and bravery, making it a remarkable but challenging family pet.

Originally bred for herding, their protective instincts can lead to aggression if they perceive a threat to their “flock,” including family members.

These powerful dogs require an owner equipped with patience and understanding to guide and control their behavior effectively, emphasizing their nature as working dogs in need of a purpose.

8. Siberian Husky

dog breeds to avoid

Siberian Huskies, known for their playful and mischievous nature, demand a lot of physical exercise and mental stimulation to stay content. They are best suited for active individuals who love spending time outdoors, given their high maintenance in terms of behavior, exercise, and grooming.

For first-time owners, Huskies might not be the ideal choice due to their considerable exercise needs and inherent stubbornness.

Unlike breeds with a strong desire to please, Huskies have a natural inclination towards independence, reflecting their breeding history for endurance and sledding, which makes them challenging to train for those new to dog ownership.

9. Alaskan Malamute

best beginner dogs

Alaskan Malamutes can be a challenging choice for a first-time dog owner due to their large size and need for constant stimulation and socialization. While they are highly intelligent and capable of responding well to training, they require a confident handler to guide them.

Stubbornness is a trait to watch out for; without proper training and leadership, a Malamute may exhibit biting or other aggressive behaviors. Their mental toughness and independence mean they demand a lot of attention and dedication.

Given their ancestral role as sled pullers, Malamutes thrive with ample exercise to keep them content and healthy.

10. Tibetan Mastiff

worst pet

Tibetan Mastiffs are affectionate, loyal, and wonderful with families, yet they are best suited for those with previous dog ownership experience. Their independent nature means they may not always follow commands, making them less ideal for obedience or agility competitions.

They tend to be calm indoors, but if left outside at night, they might bark. Early socialization with people and other animals is crucial for Tibetan Mastiffs to become more open to strangers as they grow.

Despite their high intelligence and learning capabilities, their stubbornness can make training challenging. This breed’s strong-willed character often makes them a poor match for first-time dog owners.


While certain breeds may be wonderful dogs with unique characteristics, they are often considered among the worst dog breeds for first-time pet parents due to their specific needs. These breeds typically require experienced owners who understand the nuances of dog behavior and training.

For example, the Australian Cattle dog, with its high energy and intelligence, demands an owner who can provide ample mental and physical stimulation. Similarly, a large dog breed that may excel as a guard dog, such as the Tibetan Mastiff, necessitates an experienced dog owner capable of managing their strong protective instincts and independent nature.

On the other hand, breeds like the Labrador Retriever are often recommended for new dog owners because of their adaptability, friendly nature, and eagerness to please, making them much easier to train and integrate into a family setting.

The key to a successful relationship with any dog breed lies in understanding the level of commitment and experience required.

Inexperienced owners should consider starting their dog ownership journey with breeds known for their compatibility with first-time pet parents, gradually moving up to more challenging breeds as they gain confidence and experience.

Mahvash Kazmi
Mahvash Kazmi, with a rich academic background in English Literature and Journalism, is not just a master of words but also a passionate advocate for the voiceless. Her vast experience, from teaching to insightful content creation, is underpinned by a profound love for animals and an unwavering commitment to conservation. An ardent animal lover, she often finds solace in nature's tales and the gentle purrs of her beloved Persian cat, Gracie. Her dedication to the environment and the written word combine to create truly compelling writing. With a heart that beats for the wild and the written word, she crafts compelling stories on animal issues, urging readers to coalesce for a cause.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get Your SpotOn GPS Collar with a $50 Discount

Get updates on the latest posts and more from World Animal Foundation straight to your inbox.

No Thanks